Source: https://vedic.id/resource/the-smoke-we-live-with/

Resources

# The Smoke We Live With

Kerobokan still has rice fields running right up against the villas and the yoga studios, and a few times a year the smell of burning stubble sits over all of it for days at a stretch. Everyone who lives here has an opinion about it, usually a strong one. I want to lay out the practice from both sides instead of picking one, because both sides are telling the truth about what they're seeing.

## Why farmers burn it

Burning the stubble after harvest is old practice, not a shortcut someone invented recently. It clears the field in a day instead of the week or two that cutting and hauling away the straw by hand would take, which matters when the next planting is already close behind. It's cheap, which matters more to a smallholder than to anyone writing about the smoke from a villa nearby. The ash puts some potassium back into the soil. And burning kills off a lot of what would otherwise carry over into the next crop, including the beetle locals call tomcat, which shows up in numbers when leftover stubble sits in the field and gives off a burn on skin contact that is worse than most people expect from an insect. Anyone who has dealt with a tomcat outbreak understands immediately why a farmer would rather burn.

## What it costs the people breathing it

None of that changes what the smoke does once it's in the air. It isn't a smell you can choose to ignore. It gets into houses, into studios mid-class, into the lungs of people with asthma or small children, for however many days the burn runs. People who moved here for the air, and people who were born here and never had a choice about it, end up breathing the same particulate matter and ash either way. The fact that the practice is old doesn't make the smoke less real in someone's chest this week. Both things are true at once, which is most of what makes this hard to write about honestly.

## Whose land this was first

There's a piece of this I keep circling back to, and it changes the frame more than I expected. The rice fields were here first. The farmers have been burning this stubble for as long as anyone can trace, long before a studio or a retreat or a villa went up next to their plots. People like me arrived afterward and built something that depends on those fields looking a certain way, staying quiet in a certain way, smelling a certain way, because that's part of what we're selling along with the yoga and the Ayurveda. The field didn't move in on the wellness business. The wellness business moved in on the field.

That doesn't settle the question of the smoke, but it changes who should be asking whom to adjust. A farmer doing what he's always done on his own land isn't the one who disrupted something. We are the newer thing here, with the newer expectations, asking an old practice to bend around a business model that showed up after the rice did.

## The part nobody wants to carry

Here's where it stops being simple. The complaints are easy to make and I've made them myself, standing in a studio with the windows shut and the smoke still coming through. But almost nobody complaining is also offering to pay for what would have to replace burning: a baler, a way to haul the straw out of a field that may not even have road access, somewhere for that volume of straw to go once it's out, or someone's labor to till it back into the soil instead. Those all cost money and time that a smallholder growing rice on a few plots doesn't have lying around, and the people most bothered by the smoke are rarely the ones offering to cover that gap. It's one thing to want the burning to stop. It's another to have worked out who does the clearing instead, and who pays for it.

I've tried to put something on my end of that gap rather than just naming it. I offered one of the farmers near us an alternative: bring the leftover stubble to Vedic Path instead of burning it, and we'll turn it into biochar rather than smoke. He didn't say no. But the offer still leaves the part that actually stops people: someone has to cut, gather, and carry that straw out of the field, and that labor doesn't disappear just because there's now a destination for it. An idea for the waste isn't the same as solving who hauls it there.

## No tidy ending here

I don't think the farmers burning their fields are wrong to do it, given what they're working with, and I don't think the people coughing through the smoke are wrong to be bothered either. What I keep coming back to is that we've built an entire wellness economy around this island's air and water without most of us asking what it would actually take to give the farmers next door a different option, or whether we're willing to be the ones who pay for it. So the question I'll leave open is this: if burning stopped tomorrow, who in this community is ready to show up with the alternative, and not just the opinion?

